Disrupting the Disruptors (alternative title: thoughts after a TEDx Talk)

Dancer at the TEDx talk
Dancer at the TEDx talk

One insight that I have learned in the last five years of having children in the public school system is that there is an official narrative, and then there is the reality on the ground. The two are often discordant. Because there is a political dimension to the official narrative. Who gets to frame the story, whose voices are heard and who benefits.

I was thinking about this because I went to a wonderful event in my town, TEDxJP. I spent the day listening to amazing speakers talk about their work and their insights. But there was one speaker who got up to talk about disrupting dying systems in order for them to be replaced with something healthier.

And soon as I heard the word disruption, I just knew that we were going to hear about failing schools. Because Ladies and Gentlemen, I KNOW the narrative. I know the mainstream story before it begins.

And that is exactly what happened. But it was interesting because the speaker said, “Schools are failing our children” almost as an offhanded remark, as if she felt that she didn’t even need to explain herself.

At the break, I approached her and told her I took issue with this. I said that schools are not failing our children. Schools have been abandoned and what she was mimicking was a narrative that was being used to justify privatization. She responded that she intended her speech to provoke.

Well, consider me provoked.

Because our schools are not failing. They are intentionally being starved of resources so that they cannot function. This isn’t by some organic mechanism. This by design of the ruling class so that they can justify removing publically held goods and hand them over to the control of private entities.

The education reformers may have the best intentions in the whole world. This is still DEAD WRONG. It is wrong to privatize education.

I am just a mom with a blog and a twitter account. Some of the most powerful people in the whole world are behind this. I can’t stop it. But I’ll be damned if I let people make off handed remarks that support a narrative that just isn’t true.

Advertisements

One thought on “Disrupting the Disruptors (alternative title: thoughts after a TEDx Talk)

  1. What you say in this post is so simple and true yet not getting enough volume. I live in Ohio and we are growing our charter schools because not enough people are objecting. Our charters are performing miserably compared to our traditional public schools yet they are getting funded by our Ohio legislators. We have charter school operators who contribute more than other industries to our legislators. I bet the same is true in Massachusetts and that is why it seems like a take over by people with power who make way for people with money. Please find a wider audience and tell me what I can do to help. Thanks,

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s